Most of us don’t know exactly what we’ll be doing 30, 20 or even 10 years from now. And yet, when you chose a retirement plan, you were faced with deciding just that. Which plan will serve me better for my lifetime? It’s a big decision. And in the case of your DRS retirement plan, a permanent one.
Occasionally, DRS hears from customers who question if the retirement plan they chose is the right one for them. This buyer’s remorse is a natural human reaction to many financial related situations. As you learn more, or life circumstances change, you may prioritize different features in a retirement plan.
But here’s some good news. Both Plan 2 and Plan 3 are strong, solid retirement plans designed to benefit you. Each plan includes different features that may be appealing depending on your life circumstances and preferences.
Both plans include a pension - a monthly retirement benefit you receive for life.
For more, visit Plan 2 and Plan 3 comparison.
What if you still have buyer’s remorse?
Both plans have a lot to offer. But what if you still aren’t happy with your plan? Well, fortunately there are some ways to adapt your plan to better fit your needs.
How to make Plan 2 behave more like Plan 3
Common issue: When it comes to account balance and flexibility, you might have seen how Plan 3 can really escalate a member’s retirement savings. DRS calculates your retirement pension based solely on your years of service, income, and a factor of 2%. This lack of control and flexibility over retirement income can lead some Plan 2 members to regret choosing their plan.
Potential solution: Consider additional savings through Washington’s Deferred Compensation Program (DCP) or similar voluntary retirement savings plan like 457, 403b or IRAs.
The Plan 3 members who are contributing 10 or 15% of their income into their investment account may have more flexibility for options like early retirement. For similar flexibility, some Plan 2 members may set their DCP contribution rate to be the difference between 15% and the current Plan 2 rate to treat Plan 2 more like Plan 3. Similar to the Plan 3 investment component, you can withdraw your DCP savings any time after you separate, making options like early retirement more available to you.
How to make Plan 3 behave more like Plan 2
Common issue: With a 2% defined benefit calculation, the Plan 2 pension benefit is twice as large as Plan 3, which uses a 1% calculation. Why? Because both the employer and the employee fund the Plan 2 pension. In contrast, your employer funds your Plan 3 pension benefit. Your Plan 3 contributions go into your separate investment account. This difference in pension payouts often leads some Plan 3 members to regret choosing their plan, because of the smaller, guaranteed benefit.
Potential solution: Consider annuity options offered by DRS—these provide a lifetime monthly benefit similar to your pension.
TAP annuity, purchased with your Plan 3 investments
Plan annuity, purchased using DCP or other similar savings
Annuities can often be misunderstood, and many people don’t want to give up the flexibility that an investment account with a large balance can provide. However, if you are looking for more stability in your monthly income, an annuity may be right for you. Without a built-in profit margin, Washington’s annuities provide the maximum benefit to you.
You can purchase a plan annuity using your DCP savings or other approved funding sources. The plan annuities increase your monthly pension and therefore offer the same survivor option and COLAs, as well as a balance refund. If you or your survivor pass before the original purchase amount is fully paid out, your beneficiaries will receive the remaining balance. You must purchase Plan annuities at the time of retirement.
Plan 3 members can also purchase the TAP annuity. You can buy a TAP annuity at any time after you separate from employment. The TAP annuity requires a minimum purchase amount of $25,000 but has no maximum limit. It can only be purchased using your Plan 3 investments and is a payment separate from your pension. This annuity was designed to act like a monthly pension. It guarantees an annual 3% COLA increase, a survivor continued payment option, and a balance refund if you or your survivor pass away before the annuity amount is fully paid out. You can purchase a TAP annuity at any age, but you can only purchase one per plan.
In addition to an annuity, DCP is a great way to help supplement those additional savings especially if wish you had selected a bigger contribution rate in Plan 3. DCP allows for a minimum monthly contribution of 1% and depending on your age, a yearly maximum of $23,500 or $31,000. You can learn more about limits by visiting the DCP section of our website.
Summary
With multiple options, it’s important to identify the unique strengths and advantages that will benefit you most. Take the time to learn the features your plan offers. This will help you maximize your benefits in the long run. Both plans offer powerful, flexible tools to save for retirement. If you have questions about your plan’s features, visit your plan page or contact us securely through your online account.
More resources:
Episode 21 – DCP earnings and annuitiesEpisode 44 – All about the Plan 3 TAP Annuity